The Best Pickle Relish Substitute

by Simon
Best Pickle Relish Substitute

Pickle Relish is a complementary ingredient in making burgers or as an ingredient in making tuna salad. However, sometimes we don’t have a little Pickle Relish at home, it’s all gone. So, can you still make tuna salad? Is there a Pickle Relish substitute that can help you continue serving tuna salad?

Don’t worry, we will help you here to find several substitutes that can replace Pickle Relish. It’s a little difficult to find, but it’s possible for you. Here we will provide tips for you to find a replacement for Pickle Relish so that you can still serve burgers or any dish that requires you to use Sweet Pickle Relish.

Before we find a replacement, let’s first dive into how pickles taste. This is important to make it easier for us to find a replacement.

What Is Pickle Relish?

Pickle Relish is a condiment made from chopped cucumbers, peppers pickled in salt water or vinegar and another ingredient is onions.

Sweet Pickle Relish is usually used as a complement or topping on hot dogs, burgers, and is also used in several recipes such as tuna salad and potato salad. Pickle Relish is thought to have originated in America, but now its use has spread to various corners of the world, influencing many cultures and it has been around for centuries.

Now, it is no longer difficult to find Pickle Relish, it is available in many supermarkets. If you want to save on household expenses, you can make your own Pickle Relish at home.

What Does Pickle Relish Taste Like?

What does Pickle Relish taste like? For those of you who are not familiar with pickles, this is important to know so you can find a substitute. When you don’t have pickles and want to make potato salad, burgers, etc., you already know what ingredients are suitable as the best substitute for Pickle Relish.

Pickle Relish goes well with many dishes, it is a combination of several ingredients that produce a sharp, slightly sour, slightly crunchy and sweet taste.

The Best Pickle Relish Substitute

We will share with you several ingredients that we consider to replace Pickle Relish so that you can still enjoy the dish when you have no more Pickle Relish left.

Hopefully, one of the following ingredients is suitable to replace sweet Pickle Relish.

1. Chopped Pickles

Pickle can be one of the best substitutes for Pickle Relish, this is of course in situations where you don’t have Pickle Relish but still have a little Pickle in your kitchen. The taste is sharp with a slight crunch.

So, you can use Pickle such as dill Pickle, sweet Pickle, or even use bread and butter Pickle to replace Pickle Relish, good for making potato salad, tuna salad and so on.

If you decide to use chopped pickles as a substitute for Pickle Relish, then follow these steps:

Best Pickle Relish Substitute

Best Pickle Relish Substitute

Serves: 1 Prep Time: Cooking Time:
Nutrition facts: 50 calories 10 fat
Rating: 5.0/5
( 1 voted )


  • 1 cup diced pickles
  • 1/4 cup mustard
  • 1 tablespoon pickle brine from the pickles
  • 1 tablespoon fresh dill, 1 teaspoon dried or chopped dill.


Combine all ingredients in a bowl and mix heme well

Did You Make This Recipe?
How you went with my recipes? Tag me on Instagram at @amuzingfoods

2. Cucumbers with Dill

Next, the substitute for Pickle Relish is cucumber with dill. So, you can use cucumber as an ingredient to make your pickles, to make the cucumber with dill recipe follow these steps.

  • Take one cup of cucumber and cut into cubes, remove the skin
  • 1.5 teaspoons kosher salt
  • 1/4 cup distilled white vinegar, you can also use apple cider vinegar
  • 1 or 1.5 tablespoons of sugar
  • 1.5 tablespoons dried dill, or a pinch of fresh dill.


  1. Mix the salt and diced cucumber, and stir for about 30 minutes, this will help release the cucumber liquid.
  2. While waiting, place the pan on the stove, add the vinegar and sugar and bring to a boil so that the sugar dissolves, stir frequently so that it cooks evenly.
  3. Then place the cucumbers in a glass jar, add the hot vinegar mixture to it, let it sit at room temperature until cooked.
  4. Once cool, cover tightly and put or store in the refrigerator.

Now you have cucumber pickle or a substitute for Pickle Relish in your dish.

3. Green Olives

To replace Pickle Relish, you can also use green olives. The taste is rich thanks to its sharp and slightly salty taste. If you like olives, this is your biggest advantage.

You can try using green olives as a substitute for Pickle Relish in making salads, or making burgers or omelets. How to make green olives, you can follow the method in this link.

4. Chow Chow

Chow Chow is a popular food in South America and is quite a suitable food to replace pickled relish. It is made from vegetables such as cabbage, onions, peppers and green tomatoes.

These vegetables are cut into small pieces and soaked in vinegar and spices. Chow chow relish is a suitable substitute for pickle relish because of its sharp taste. Chow chow is often added to salads and sandwiches. Sometimes it is also added to seasoning grilled meat. This is a substitute for pickle relish that you should try.

5. Chutneys

There is another best substitute for pickle relish, this is Chutney. Chutney is a condiment or sauce that originates from India.

What is Chutney? This is an Indian sauce made from a combination of fruit and vegetables and spices. The taste can be tart or sweet. In each region, they sometimes make Chutney with different flavors. But there are basic ingredients that are mostly the same. The basic ingredients in making Chutney are mango, apple and apricot.

Chutney often tastes spicy because there are lots of spices in it such as ginger, coriander and cumin. This is sometimes used as a main dish or sometimes used as an appetizer. For those of you who make sandwiches, Chutney is a rich, flavorful spread.

So, with such taste, Chutney is the best substitute for pickle relish.

6. Sauerkraut

Sauerkraut is a German food, it is fermented cabbage. The way to make it is to cut the cabbage into thin slices, and then soak it in salt water. Over time, the soaked cabbage will break down and produce a sour, sharp and crunchy product.

Sauerkraut is often used as a pickle relish substitute or as a side dish at meals. It is even better to enjoy while drinking a cup of warm tea.

The Best Calabrian Chili Substitute
Twisted Tea Nutrition Facts and Calories

Sauerkraut is almost the same as Kimchi, Sauerkraut is a rich source of probiotics that benefit digestion and this has great benefits for human well-being.

FAQs About Pickle Relish Substitute

Some common questions you might want to ask are related to pickle relish.

Is pickle relish just chopped pickles?

No, in making pickle relish there is a basic ingredient of chopped pickle juice, but pickle relish also contains ingredients such as sugar, vinegar and spices. These pickles are preserved using sugar, vinegar and a combination of both.

Although finely chopped pickles and minced pickles can be used as substitutes for pickle relish, they are different.

Can I use sweet pickle relish as a substitute for dill pickle relish?

Yes, sweet pickle relish can be used as a substitute for dill pickle relish, but it is important for you to know that sweet pickle relish has a sweeter taste. So, this can change the profile or affect the taste of your food.

Are there any non-pickle substitutes for pickle relish?

How am I not a fan of pickle relish, is there a non-pickle substitute? Yes, you can use bell peppers, celery, cucumber, onion. All ingredients are finely chopped and then mixed together. This food will provide crunch to your cooking as provided by pickle relish.

Can I substitute pickle relish in deviled eggs?

Yes, some of my friends even prefer to eat finely chopped pickle or capers or olives in their boiled egg instead of using pickle relish. I sometimes make burgers using just lettuce and chopped cucumber.

You may also like

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More

Adblock Detected

Please support us by disabling your AdBlocker extension from your browsers for our website.